Our Hidden Outpost on Barnegat Bay!​

You don’t need a plane ticket to escape to the islands. At Caribbean Pete’s Key West Outpost, we bring the laid-back energy of the Florida Keys straight to the Jersey shore—right on the water at Key Harbor Marina.

With bay breezes, lighthouse views, Caribbean rhythms, and bold island flavors, every visit feels like a mini vacation. From crispy conch fritters to smoky jerk wings and a Key Lime Pie that tastes like sunshine, it’s easy to forget you’re still in the Garden State.

Flip flops encouraged. Island time starts here.

​Call for Reservations - 732.503.8042

Signature Outpost Favorites

🔥 Our Famous Jerk Wings: Smoky, spicy, and packed with Caribbean flavor. These are the wings everyone talks about—and comes back for.
🌴 Conch Fritters: Golden, crispy, and island-authentic. A perfect start to any bayside meal.
🥧 Our Version of Key Lime Pie: Bright, creamy, and just the right balance of sweet and tart—Florida Keys inspired, Jersey perfected.
Explore the Full Menu 

​Stow Your Own Spirits

​We’re proudly BYOB, so bring your favorite wine or spirit and settle in bayside. Want something fun and shareable? Our Sangria Pitcher Kits and Pour-Over Cocktails are made for long sunsets and good company.
Perfect for:
  • Sunset dinners
  • Group nights
  • Celebrations by the bay
  • Dock N Dine
  • Soaking up the Island Vibes!

​Serving the Most Magical Coffee on Earth!

​Joffrey's Coffee & Tea Co. is the Official Specialty Coffee of Walt Disney World® Resort, Disneyland® Resort, and Disney Vacation Club®
From our House Blend, Espresso Drinks to the Shakin' Jamaican™ 

High Tides & Island Vibes

  • Located directly in Key Harbor Marina
  • Dock & Dine
  • ​Waterfront Dining
  • Bay & lighthouse views
  • Caribbean music setting the mood
  • Relaxed, fun, vacation-style atmosphere
Whether you’re arriving by car or boat, the moment you step in, the pace slows and the island feeling takes over.

Events

Follow us on Facebook & Instagram!​
Follow our Facebook for up to date events.